Camera covering a staff-only private area
A break room, a changing room or a toilet is where people expect not to be watched. GDPR and UK GDPR Art. 5 (fairness) is where the question starts; California Labor Code 435, New York Labor Law 203-c, New York Penal Law 250.45, StGB section 201a and Code penal article 226-1 each reach a camera over a restroom, locker room, changing room or other room protected from view, and are cited where the site is there; the NSW Workplace Surveillance Act and the ACT Workplace Privacy Act name these places for sites there. These cameras are listed at the top of the register.
- When it is raised
- Raised on every camera whose coverage reads as a break room, changing room or toilet, where a regime or a named law is placed at the site.
- The question
- Why does a camera cover this area, and can it be moved or switched off?
- For
- your lawyer
- The column that settles it
- the analytics or coverage column
- On the row
- a numbered delta and the words "private area" in small capitals; an outlined delta where it rests on a blank column
Clauses by regime
GDPR (the EU General Data Protection Regulation)
GDPR Art. 5Principles relating to processing of personal dataPrinciples relating to processing of personal data. Process personal data lawfully, fairly and in a transparent manner; collect it for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes and do not process it further in a way incompatible with those purposes; keep it adequate, relevant and limited to what the purpose needs; keep it accurate and up to date, erasing or rectifying inaccurate data without delay; keep it in a form permitting identification no longer than the purpose requires; and secure it against unauthorised or unlawful processing and against accidental loss, destruction or damage using appropriate technical or organisational measures. The controller is responsible for all six principles and must be able to demonstrate compliance with them.
UK GDPR
UK GDPR Art. 5Principles relating to processing of personal dataArticle 5 Principles relating to processing of personal data. Personal data must be processed lawfully, fairly and transparently; collected, whether from the data subject or otherwise, for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes and not further processed by or for the controller in a way incompatible with the purposes for which the controller collected it (Article 8A decides compatibility); adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary; accurate and kept up to date, with inaccurate data erased or rectified without delay; kept in identifiable form no longer than necessary, with longer storage only for archiving, research or statistics carried out under Article 84B; and secured against unauthorised or unlawful processing and accidental loss, destruction or damage. The controller is responsible for, and must be able to demonstrate, compliance (accountability). Article 5(3) adds that processing is not lawful merely because it is compatible with the original purpose: a lawful basis under Article 6 is still needed.
Australian Privacy Principles (APPs)
APP APP 3Collection of solicited personal informationAPP 3 - Collection of solicited personal information. Only collect personal information that is reasonably necessary for the entity's functions or activities, by lawful and fair means.
California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA, as amended by the CPRA)
CCPA s. 1798.100(c)Keep collection and use necessary and proportionateKeep collection and use necessary and proportionate. Gathering, using, keeping and passing on a consumer's data must go no further than needed, and in proportion, for the purpose it was gathered for, or for another disclosed purpose that fits the context of collection. Processing that drifts into purposes incompatible with those is not allowed.
California Labor Code section 435 (recording in restrooms and locker rooms)
Cal. Lab. Code s. 435(a)Do not cause an audio or video recording of an employee in a restroom, locker room or changing room without a court order435(a) Do not cause an audio or video recording of an employee in a restroom, locker room or changing room without a court order. An employer must not arrange, order or permit any audio or video capture of a worker who is inside a restroom, a locker room, or a room set aside for staff to change clothes, unless a court order allows it. The ban is on causing the recording, so it reaches cameras and microphones installed by contractors, landlords or security vendors at the employer's request, and recording functions of access-control or monitoring systems that capture those rooms.
Cal. Lab. Code s. 435(b)Do not use a recording made in violation of the section for any purpose435(b) Do not use a recording made in violation of the section for any purpose. Any recording that breaches the section is off limits to the employer for every purpose: not for discipline, not for investigations, not for litigation, not for security review. The section applies to private and public employers alike, except the federal government. The practical control is a rule that any footage or audio discovered to come from a protected room is quarantined and destroyed, not viewed or relied on.
New York Labor Law sections 203-c and 203-d (recording in restrooms; personal identifying information)
NY Lab. Law s. 203-c(1)Do not cause a video recording of an employee in a restroom, locker room or changing room without a court order203-c(1) Do not cause a video recording of an employee in a restroom, locker room or changing room without a court order. An employer must not arrange or permit video capture of a worker inside a restroom, a locker room or a room set aside for staff to change clothes, unless a court order allows it. The duty is on causing the recording, so cameras installed by landlords, contractors or security vendors at the employer's request are caught, as are cameras outside the room whose field of view reaches inside.
NY Lab. Law s. 203-c(2)Do not use a recording made in violation of the section for any purpose203-c(2) Do not use a recording made in violation of the section for any purpose. A video recording made in violation of the section may not be used by the employer for any purpose, including discipline, investigation, litigation or security review. The control is a procedure that quarantines and destroys any such footage once discovered.
New York Penal Law Article 250 (eavesdropping and surveillance offences)
NY Penal Law s. 250.45(3)Do not install or use an imaging device to surreptitiously view or record people in bedrooms, changing rooms, fitting rooms, restrooms, toilets, bathrooms, washrooms, showers or guest rooms250.45(3) Do not install or use an imaging device to surreptitiously view or record people in bedrooms, changing rooms, fitting rooms, restrooms, toilets, bathrooms, washrooms, showers or guest rooms. Deliberately using or fitting an imaging device to covertly watch, broadcast or record someone in a bedroom, changing room, fitting room, restroom, toilet, bathroom, washroom or shower, or in a room assigned to a guest at a hotel, motel or inn, without that person's knowledge or agreement, is the second-degree offence. There is a rebuttable presumption that the actor had no legitimate purpose.
NY Penal Law s. 250.45(1), (2), (4) and (5)Do not surreptitiously view, broadcast or record a person dressing or undressing or their intimate parts without consent250.45 Do not surreptitiously view, broadcast or record a person dressing or undressing or their intimate parts without consent. The second-degree offence (class E felony) includes covertly viewing, broadcasting or recording, with an imaging device one uses or installs, a person who is dressing or undressing or that person's intimate parts, in a protected setting and without their knowledge or agreement, for amusement, entertainment or profit, to degrade or abuse, or for sexual arousal or gratification; recording under a person's clothing without consent; and recording in an identifiable manner a person engaged in sexual conduct in a place of reasonable privacy without consent.
German Criminal Code (StGB) sections 201 and 201a (the spoken word and intimate images)
StGB § 201a(1) no. 1Do not create or transmit images of a person in a dwelling or a room specially protected from view that violate their intimate privacy201a(1) no. 1 Do not create or transmit images of a person in a dwelling or a room specially protected from view that violate their intimate privacy. Whoever, without authorisation, creates or transmits an image of another person who is in a dwelling or in a room specially protected against view (for example a changing room, toilet, treatment room or sauna) and thereby violates that person's most personal sphere of life is punishable. The legitimate-interest exception in subsection 4 does not apply to this offence.
French Code penal article 226-1 (capturing words, images or location)
Code penal Art. 226-1, 2°Do not fix, record or transmit the image of a person in a private place without their consent226-1 2 Do not fix, record or transmit the image of a person in a private place without their consent. Fixing, recording or transmitting the image of a person who is in a private place (lieu prive: a dwelling, hotel room, changing room, private office or any place not open to the public) without that person's consent, with the intention of invading the intimacy of private life, is punishable. Live transmission is caught as well as recording.
Code penal Art. 226-1 (presumed consent)Rely on presumed consent only where the act was done openly and the person could object, and obtain parental consent for minors226-1 Rely on presumed consent only where the act was done openly and the person could object, and obtain parental consent for minors. Where the acts in 1 and 2 were performed in the sight and with the knowledge of the persons concerned (au vu et au su des interesses) and they did not object although able to do so, their consent is presumed. That presumption does not extend to geolocation under 3. Where the acts concern a minor, consent must come from the holders of parental authority, with respect for article 372-1 of the Civil Code.
Named, not quoted
- Workplace Surveillance Act (NSW) 2005: notice before camera surveillance of employees starts, visible cameras and signs, and no surveillance in change rooms, toilets or showers (New South Wales; named, not quoted)
- Workplace Privacy Act (ACT) 2011: notice of workplace surveillance and the areas where it may not be carried out (Australian Capital Territory; named, not quoted)
- Surveillance Devices Act (Vic) 1999: listening devices, and optical surveillance in workplace toilets, washrooms, change rooms and lactation rooms (Victoria; named, not quoted)